The online directory lists 47 members of the Shimer College class of 1999:
- Siddhi Aryal
- Burton Ashbach
- Lara Ashbach
- Colin Bailey
- Leo Boler III
- Frank Braun
- Will Burdick
- April Burton
- Heather Shaffer Carpenter
- Yatta Carter
- Jon Cotner
- Sara Davila
- Edith Draegert
- Lynda Fischer
- Amy Frothingham
- Aaron Gilliam
- Jacqueline Harris
- Matthew Harrison
- Masato Ishibashi
- Sally Johnson
- Brandee Cooper Kandle
- Anastasia Kruglyashova
- Ariella Lake
- Richard Lee
- Leah Lickliter
- John Love
- Ted Manner
- Rosemary McGuire
- Jennifer Moran
- Merry Nelson
- Renee O'Brien
- Carol O'Connell
- Michelle Oliva
- Kari Quagliano
- Shannon Ramesh Ramey
- Kristina Salmi
- Alia Savage
- Rachael Feinsod Shivers
- Bonnie Simmons
- Pam Smith
- Yves St. Vil
- Rebecca Sundin
- Nickolas Vecchioni
- Sarah Biscardi Wellings
- Ellen Whitehouse
- Asa Wilke
- Tatiana Young