The online directory lists 116 members of the Shimer College class of 1974:
- Jessie Cohen Anderson
- Joel Armstrong
- Gordon Asselstine
- Philip Bash
- John Bassette
- Karen Berk
- Michael Berst
- Jay Blume
- Abbey Botkin
- Seth Brody
- Valerie Brown
- William Burke
- Buffie Burket
- Elizabeth Buschor
- John Butler
- Donald Cameron
- Peggy Carey
- Donald Carlin
- Linda Keres Carter
- Richard Chamberlain
- John Clegg
- Randall Clutter
- Richard Conrad
- John Cool
- Robert Cordova
- Roy Cummins
- Janice Guidotti DeQuinzo
- Richard Dehnert
- Jody Offenberg Deloria
- Richard DiSanto
- Roman Draba
- Susan Duitsman
- Jon Eggleston
- George Eigenhauser
- Jill Burger Ely
- Phillip Erman
- Albert Fancsali
- Brian Wonder Feldman
- Richard Frost
- Michael Gans
- Martha Garber
- Pamela Lyons Garland
- Barbara Gaynor
- Scott Gibbs
- William Gillies
- Jonna Wheeler Gosser
- Bobbie Groth
- Mary Therese Grund
- Michael Gueft
- Thomas Hachiya
- Taylor Hanley
- Robert Hawney
- Theodore Hebelka
- Jeffrey Heehs
- Roger Hite
- Sandra Schmidt Hockenbury
- Ronald Hoeflin
- Robert Holub
- Marc Horin
- Cynthia Levin Howard
- Robert Jaeger
- Michael Jones
- Randall Kahan
- Deborah Kaplan
- Lester Kaplan
- Ruth Kavanaugh
- Mary Kennedy
- Alan Kepner
- John Klockau
- Edward Kotin
- Michele LaNoue LaNoue
- Susan Lachman
- Susan Landfield
- Chris Larsen
- Michael Lauer
- Suzanne Smarr Lauer
- Roy Lee
- Kathy Long
- Steven Long
- John Malone
- Laura Baum Mandabach
- Joan McCready
- Patrick McGuire
- William McKenzie
- John Meinrath
- Susan McKee Morris
- James Murray
- John Nausieda
- Ronald Olson
- Jonathan Parker
- Michael Passo
- Laura Pinyan
- James Quick
- Spencer Quick
- Roxanne Plummer Rios
- Jackie Nolen Rudich
- Janet Hammond Rupp
- Mark Samuelson
- Jane Nothmann Sender
- Anna D'Aversa Stachowski
- Helen Sapp Stolfa
- Cita Strauss
- David Sueme
- Joan Sutherland
- Patricia Hicks Syme
- Marilyn Taillon
- Elizabeth Adams Terrell
- Louis Torch
- Steven Waller
- Virginia White
- Thomas Winke
- William Woods
- Gregg Wright
- Carita Wyant
- Steven Yancey
- Paul Yessler