The online directory lists 135 members of the Shimer College class of 1965:
- Frances Screnock Adeney
- Burton Atwood
- Constance Ballard
- Sandra Powers Bass
- Karleen Dunbar Bensinger
- Steven Blank
- Ann Bornstein
- Charles Boston
- Marguerite Boudreau
- Jann Moser Bowlus
- Allan Brandt
- Daniel Braun
- Sarah Brown Brown
- John Buchanan
- Macyl Burke
- Michael Cafferata
- Robert Carey
- William Carroll
- Nelson Cauthen
- Susan Chambers
- E. Charbonneau
- John Christos
- Frances Andrews Cole
- Diana Corcoran
- Philip Cottle
- Roger Cronin
- Matt Cushner
- Marilyn Bean Daum
- John DeWeerdt
- Richard Deitch
- Joseph DiCola
- Bruce Dunwell
- Lynn Gustavson Easterwood
- Eric Eisenbise
- Kinsey English
- Carol Sickinger Epstein
- Robert Falk
- Paul Franz
- Leilani Ravn Fretz
- Kenneth Freund
- Martha Fuller Fuller
- John Gawlick
- Alexandra Lazowski Gerrard
- Richard Gleasman
- William Goldman
- Daniel Gooze
- David Gustin
- Thomas Hall
- Phyllis Hansen
- Michael Harris
- Trudy Century Heller
- Michael Houlihan
- Thomas Hynes
- Robert Ingols
- Robert Jacklin
- Richard Janicki
- Edward Jochim
- Craig Johnson
- Nancy Johnston
- Sharon Schraudenbach Karpinski
- Robert Kilburn
- Jonathan Klein
- Ellen McGrath Kovel
- Sheila Gaulke Lassman
- Edward Laughlin
- Jack Lazareck
- Theodore Leonard
- Edward Lewis
- M. Limper
- Lawrence Linck
- Sidney Lissner
- Bradley Lush
- Marjorie Marlowe
- Karen Martin
- Donald McCabe
- William McConnell
- Danny McMullin
- Richard Means
- Kirkland Merley
- Arthur Michener
- A. Miller
- James Miller
- Wanda Milnes
- Mimi Bistrow Montgomery
- Robert Moon
- Pam O'Leary Morence
- James Nice
- David Noble
- Rosemary O'Loughlin O'Loughlin-Richey
- Ninka Hainer Oros
- Lawrence Osterberg
- Christina Otake
- Richard Palmer
- Frank Parry
- David Perkins
- John Perkins
- Cynthia Duskin Petersen
- Bruce Petesch
- Peggy Piers
- Nicholas Pippenger
- Philip Podolner
- Myrna Spilky Poticha
- Richard Pottinger
- Steven Prindle
- Janet Hyland Prodan
- Richard Rabe
- John Randall
- Francine Netter Roberson
- Mary Rogers
- John Roth
- Sidney Scott
- Thomas Screnock
- Charles Seastone
- Michael Sennott
- Shelley Christensen Shull
- Ferne Siefert
- Joseph Skold
- Jeffrey Smith
- Susan Clark Swafford
- Aili Sargent Taback
- Elizabeth Auerbach Taleporos
- James Tamkin
- Deborah Wheelock Taylor
- Joseph Tourtelot
- Jules Traxler
- Stanley Trumbull
- John Tuthill
- Rodney Underwood
- John Van Paasschen
- J. Veech
- James Vizard
- Charles Vrhel
- Ardis Thompson Waters
- Douglas Wolfe
- Judith Gillespie Wright