The online directory lists 108 members of the Shimer College class of 1963:
- John Adinamis
- Diana Scheuring Altman
- Kenneth Anton
- Thomas Atkinson
- Webster Ball
- Gene Bass
- William Baumgartner
- Shmuel Cahan Ben Menachem
- Gaye Gilbert Gilbert Benson
- Daniel Blakeslee Blake
- Madeleine Bohn
- Diane Westol Bradtke
- Bobbie Irwin Brinson
- Robert Bukowski
- Kenneth Burg
- Harry Coblens
- Morgan Cole
- Frances Colehour
- Harry Cultra
- Elizabeth Clark Dawson
- Lawrence Dawson
- Sydney Diamond
- Donald Dickinson
- C. Dobson
- Stephen Dobyns
- Paul Doepel
- Marnie Bennett Donovan
- Fredric Dulin
- Judith Myers Duncan
- Robert Duncan
- Lee Eakright
- Oliver Easterwood
- Beulah Catlin Edghill
- Leo Fitts
- William Fonvielle
- Donald Gale
- Frank Gatke
- Suzanne Gillette
- Richard Gloede
- Geoffrey Goldsmith
- Jonathan Goldstein
- Constance Gordon
- Jon Hardie
- Edmund Hoskin
- Barbara Ireland
- Susan Wellman Jakusz
- Phoebe Kindig John
- David Johnson
- David Judd
- Carl D Kadie
- Kenneth Kaiz
- Edward Keele
- Jill King
- Linda Nordquest Kithcart
- Andrew Klinger
- Catherine Herrmann Knuth
- Nancy Summers Koehl
- Joseph Kubalek
- Margaret Haas Kuntzelman
- William Leon
- Michael Lipsey
- Ann Lipsky
- David Lunn
- Harris Maclay
- Bruce Marcus
- Sharon Cox Marquitz
- Larry Mason
- Phyllis Bagwill McChesney
- Thomas McGoldrick
- Michael McKee
- Clark McKeown
- John McMillen
- Robert Middleton
- Sys Morch
- Daniel Natale
- Alice Hawley Neuschwanger
- Newton Noble
- Clark O'Shaughnessy
- Patricia Ostrander
- Dennis Ottavi
- Daniel Ozelis
- James Papandrea
- Paul Pierog
- Penelope Platt
- Ronald Ramsey
- Ellen Robbins
- Sydney Rose
- M. Kuklin Roseman
- Robert Rugg
- Thomas Ryan
- Patricia Samuel
- Steven Schoenberg
- Thomas Schutz
- Walter Sheldon
- James Sherman
- Barbara Miles Skean
- Robert Slowik
- J. Soderlund
- Bruce Sparler
- Robert Steuernagel
- David Templeton
- Frank Terry
- DJ Turner
- Rayda Heath Vega Heath
- F. Vosse
- Mark Wagner
- Frederick Weil
- Morris Weinstein